News on the people who matter.
News › Law
Law

Sony defeats £2 billion UK class action over PlayStation Store prices

A London tribunal found Sony was not dominant and said rival consoles keep its digital game prices in check.

A PlayStation 5 console standing upright on its base with a DualSense controller in front of it on a wooden table, in black and white
PlayStation 5 and DualSense controller. Photo by Osh33m / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0), converted to black and white

Sony on Tuesday defeated a London class action worth almost £2 billion ($2.6 billion) after the Competition Appeal Tribunal threw out claims that its PlayStation Store inflated digital game prices for about 12.2 million UK consumers, Reuters reported.

The unanimous decision hands a substantial victory to businesses defending competition claims over closed digital platforms, ICLG News said. The case was the third against a major tech company to reach trial since the start of 2025, following a win for claimants against Apple in October last year, according to Reuters.

The three-member panel, chaired by Ben Tidswell and including Lord Richardson and Derek Ridyard, found that Alex Neill Class Representative Ltd had failed to show Sony broke competition law, according to the tribunal's judgment. The company's sole director is Alex Neill, a consumer rights advocate. The claim covered UK purchases of digital content on PlayStation consoles from August 2016 to Feb. 12, 2026.

Neill's company filed the claim in August 2022. When the tribunal certified it in November 2023, it was valued at up to £5 billion, according to Brick Court Chambers, whose barristers acted for Sony. By trial, the class was seeking about £1.49 billion in damages, or about £1.97 billion with interest.

The case centered on how Sony sells games. Digital games and add-ons for its consoles can be bought only through the PlayStation Store, where Sony generally targets a margin of about 30% on third-party sales, ICLG News reported. The class argued that this setup amounted to an abuse of a dominant position and that retail prices would have been about 20% lower without it.

Sony countered that it had invested years and billions in an integrated gaming platform that benefits consumers, Reuters reported. It said rivals Nintendo and Microsoft's Xbox use similar models, and that the lawsuit amounted to letting third parties free-ride on its investment by opening rival stores on the PlayStation.

The tribunal sided with Sony on market definition, the point on which the whole claim turned. It rejected the class's proposed market made up only of PlayStation games and add-ons. Physical games are likely to be significant substitutes, the panel found, and players who own several consoles or play across platforms limit what Sony can charge.

The panel instead adopted the market Sony proposed, in which PlayStation competes with Xbox and Nintendo as complete systems. It concluded that "competition and rivalry at the system level do provide an effective means to regulate pricing and competitive conduct" in the aftermarket for games, ICLG News reported. Lawyers for the class accepted in closing that the claim would fail on that finding, and the class had not offered an alternative market.

A Nintendo Switch 2, a black Xbox Series X with stickers and a white PlayStation 5 side by side on a gray table in front of shelves of video games
A Nintendo Switch 2, Xbox Series X and PlayStation 5. The tribunal found the three compete as complete gaming systems. Photo by InclusiveGameLab / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

The tribunal went on to reject the remaining allegations in case its market ruling is overturned on appeal. It was not satisfied that Sony was dominant in any relevant market. It found the claimed 20% price gap was not made out. It said opening the PlayStation to third-party stores would raise unresolved security concerns and require material changes to the platform, setting the case apart from the tribunal's earlier ruling against Apple's App Store. Sony's returns, measured across the PlayStation system as a whole, were not shown to be excessive or unfair.

Stephanie Burns, senior vice president and general counsel at Sony Interactive Entertainment, said the ruling affirms the company's business model, according to Reuters. Sony sold 8 million PlayStation 5 consoles worldwide between October and December 2025.

Neill said in a statement to ICLG News that she was disappointed by the judgment and was weighing her options, including whether to appeal. She said "we believe these were important issues to test on behalf of consumers" and that the case had been five years in the making. The claim was funded by Woodsford, with Robert Palmer KC of Monckton Chambers representing the class. Daniel Beard KC, also of Monckton Chambers, led for Sony, instructed by Linklaters.

Other UK cases against tech companies are still running. Apple is seeking to appeal its loss over the App Store, and a trial of a claim against Google began in October, Reuters reported. More coverage of court rulings and regulation is on the 1NFLUENC3 Law Sector page.

The tribunal will hold a hearing in the week of Dec. 14 on costs and any applications for permission to appeal, the judgment said.

Sources

  1. Reuters reported · https://www.japantimes.co.jp/business/2026/11/18/sony-uk-playstation-price-lawsuit/
  2. tribunal's judgment · https://www.catribunal.org.uk/sites/cat/files/2026-11/15277722%20Alex%20Neill%20Class%20Representative%20Limited%20v%20Sony%20Interactive%20Entertainment%20Europe%20Limited%3B%20Sony%20Interactive%20Entertainment%20Network%20Europe%20Limited%3B%20and%20Sony%20Interac.pdf
  3. Brick Court Chambers · https://www.brickcourt.co.uk/news/detail/competition-appeal-tribunal-dismisses-2-billion-playstation-class-action-against-sony
  4. ICLG News reported · https://iclg.com/news/sony-defeats-2-billion-playstation-class-action/
  5. Law Sector page · https://1nfluenc3.com/law/
  6. Sony defeats £2 billion U.K. claim over PlayStation Store pricing (Reuters via The Japan Times) · https://www.japantimes.co.jp/business/2026/11/18/sony-uk-playstation-price-lawsuit/
  7. Competition Appeal Tribunal dismisses £2 billion PlayStation class action against Sony · https://www.brickcourt.co.uk/news/detail/competition-appeal-tribunal-dismisses-2-billion-playstation-class-action-against-sony
  8. Sony defeats £2 billion PlayStation class action | ICLG · https://iclg.com/news/sony-defeats-2-billion-playstation-class-action/
  9. 1527/7/7/22 Alex Neill Class Representative Limited v Sony - case page · https://www.catribunal.org.uk/cases/15277722-alex-neill-class-representative-limited

Corrections: team@1nfluenc3.com

How we source and correct: Editorial Standards. Spot an error? Corrections.